This week’s readings focus on images and artifacts. As public historians we will use artifacts and images a great deal, whether they are photographs, objects inside a display case, landscape structures or buildings.
The Inland Northwest contains structures that are used as evidence of the
growth and development of Spokane, from large mansions to public parks and
structures left from Expo ’74. In
Henry Matthews' essay Kirtland Cutter: Spokane's Architect, Cutter
drafts mansions for the rich investors who relocate to the Inland Northwest
from the east coast. The large houses reaffirm that Spokane is an industrial
and economic player in national affairs, like larger cities in the east and
they could also have, "through Cutter's imagination and professional
skill, the symbols of old wealth"(169) linking the old world with the
frontier. In J. Williams T. Youngs' essay Thinking Globally, Acting
Locally, he discusses the efforts of local leaders to renew urban Spokane
to give the city a stronger core. This essay is a great bookend to the story of
Spokane's founding, development, growth, decline and ultimately urban renewal
and "federalization" through Expo '74. The focus of the expo on
environmentalism was supported internationally and nationally, giving Spokane
the opportunity to be a cause of global change, instead of reacting to it.
The next couple of chapters in Thrush's book
explore the next step of Seatle's transformation on the eve of the Second
World War. He points out how native images are used by urban Seattle to connect them
with their “place story” even though the native people no longer had an active
role in the historical interpretation. Seattle became "a city that used
Indian images and stories to make sense of itself, real Native people, and
especially those not affiliated with totem poles, were pushed to the margins of
urban society"(149-150). The retelling of Seattle’s history was taken
up by two different organizations with differing viewpoints. The Pioneers
wanted to remember the times before urban expansion and keep alive the
connection to the Denny landing and first settlers. They used the memories of
the local natives to supplement their narration of the past. The Tilikums used
Indian imagery to tell their version of local imperial history and promote
their social organization. The actual indigenous population had either moved
outside the city or became absorbed into urban society. Their images, however
distorted, remain as their representatives to the land that was once theirs.
Pictures used in the Alaska-Yukon-Pacific-Expedition. The top photo is the Spokane building. (courtesy of Wiki Images)
The analysis of photographs
discussed in Nearby History is
important for our project because we will use them to research our
buildings. I thought it was interesting how Kyvig and Marty showed how
photographs were edited even before Photoshop. I would have never considered
looking for evidence of editing when studying older photographs. Artifacts are also
important to Public Historians because we will use them to bring history to the
public. I was also not aware of the newer discipline of Industrial Archaeology.
The time period of most of our ghost signs will be from is the period of
industrial growth in Spokane.
I enjoyed looking at the
ghost signs in San Francisco. My favorite was the second slide with the letter “O.”
I feel like that one would be fun and challenging to research. It almost looks
like a sign for a hotel that was housed inside the building, but you never
know. A couple of the ghost signs they found were in great shape. I wonder if
they were redone or just preserved well?
Great post, Erin. You're really good at distilling big ideas into simple statements. I thought the pre-Photoshop editing was interesting too. Had he not provided the "before" image, I would never have known the picture had been altered so dramatically. I also liked the way the photographer expresses the strict Victorian morality of the era in his changes. Or maybe it's just that the guy in the picture looks really awkward and creepy with his arm around his wife (presumably).
ReplyDeleteWell then we agree about the Tikkums and the Pioneers from Seattle. Interesting how you forgot to mention King Cole. I agree Expo 74 was a excellent end to a book on Spokane History.
ReplyDeleteBest,
Ax